The gerrymander cartoon and a governor’s troublesome surname
The gerrymander cartoon joined a Massachusetts governor's surname to the name of an animal. Its creature represented an electoral district, and the animal was a salamander. Governor Elbridge Gerry signed the state's redistricting law on February 11, 1812. The resulting political controversy gave his name a life in English beyond his public offices. Jennifer Davis's history for the Law Library of Congress identifies the plan as an attempt to preserve Republican power against the Federalists in the approaching election.
The controversy concerned representation in the Massachusetts Senate. Davis reports that the redistricting returned 29 Republican senators and 11 Federalists. In Essex County, the district's long, curved outline supplied the visual starting point for the satire. On March 26, 1812, the Boston Gazette published the creature under a description presenting it as a new species of monster. The historical cartoon belonged to a specific state election dispute, with recognizable town boundaries underneath its added animal features.
Earlier newspaper coverage had already attacked the geography. David Wilton's word history identifies a Boston Gazette extra edition of March 9, 1812, containing maps of Worcester and Essex Counties. It described the Essex arrangement with comparisons to a crooked S and nested eggshells, without yet using gerrymander. The gerrymander cartoon followed later that month. Its accompanying prose invented Doctor Watergruel, a mock scientific authority who classified and named the creature. The word thus appeared within an extended piece of political ridicule rather than as a neutral geographical description.
The supposed conversation that produced the pun has a less secure history. Wilton distinguishes the documented newspaper appearance from later accounts of an editor comparing a map to a salamander and another speaker substituting Gerry's name. The exact coiner remains uncertain. He identifies John Russell of the Gazette as the likeliest candidate and Elkanah Tisdale as the probable creator of the drawing. Reprints carried both the picture and the word beyond the first newspaper appearance. Those printed appearances are distinct from the disputed recollections about an office conversation.
A later reference work illustrates the changing account. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica entry repeated John Fiske's version from Civil Government in the United States, published in 1890. That telling placed the map in Benjamin Russell's office and credited the added animal features to Gilbert Stuart. It therefore differed from Wilton's identification of Tisdale and his caution about the speakers. The gerrymander cartoon acquired a story about its creation as well as a documented publication history. The two kinds of evidence have not always assigned the same people the same roles.
The 1911 entry also preserved electoral figures and the law's short duration. It reported 50,164 Democratic votes returning 29 senators, against 51,766 Federalist votes returning 11. Its account of Essex County described a change from five Federalist senators to three Democrats and two Federalists. The law was repealed in 1813 after the Federalists regained control of the legislature. The entry also recorded an established soft-g pronunciation, while noting that the governor's surname had originally supplied a hard g. A temporary electoral arrangement had produced a much more durable word.
Gerry's earlier public career had included a different dispute over representation and governmental power. The National Archives' Massachusetts biography records his graduation from Harvard in 1762, entry into the family trading business, and election to the colonial legislature in 1772. He entered the Continental Congress in 1776 and signed the Declaration of Independence. At the Constitutional Convention of 1787, he chaired the committee associated with the Great Compromise. He ultimately refused to sign the Constitution, objecting to the absence of a bill of rights and other features of the proposed government.
Archivist Greg Bradsher's detailed account describes Gerry's effort on September 12, 1787, to add a national bill of rights. George Mason supported the motion, but the convention rejected it. Gerry then pursued specific guarantees and joined Mason and Edmund Randolph in seeking another convention. When the completed document was signed, Gerry withheld his signature. His subsequent position favored amendments rather than the complete rejection of the Constitution. Bradsher's account records both the objections and Gerry's eventual willingness to support the adopted system.
The National Archives biography places Gerry's election as Massachusetts governor in 1810, after earlier unsuccessful campaigns. His administration then became associated with the redistricting measure and the hostile pun. He later served as James Madison's vice president in 1813 and 1814. By the time the 1911 reference entry explained the gerrymander cartoon and its name, the term encompassed unfair partisan arrangements beyond the original Essex district. Gerry died in office in 1814 and was buried in Washington's Congressional Cemetery.
- Jennifer Davis, Elbridge Gerry and the Monstrous Gerrymander, Law Library of Congress — blogs.loc.gov
- David Wilton, Gerrymander, Wordorigins.org: 1812 newspaper evidence and attribution — www.wordorigins.org
- Encyclopaedia Britannica, 11th edition (1911), Gerrymander, historical entry — en.wikisource.org
- National Archives, The Founding Fathers: Massachusetts, Elbridge Gerry biography — www.archives.gov
- Greg Bradsher, A Founding Father in Dissent, Prologue (2006) — www.archives.gov